CEG’s Journal

How to Be Yourself in a Relationship Without Fear of Rejection

I came across a post by Dr. Kiana Berry, a pelvic floor physical therapist, that said something I found interesting.

She was talking about how much time women spend worrying about the things they assume their partners are judging them for. Wearing a bonnet. Having on granny panties. Being silly. Trying something new and not being particularly good at it.

And how sometimes, the person we’re so worried about being judged by isn’t even thinking about those things.

We are.

And I sat with that for a minute because, well, damn.

How many times have I decided somebody was going to have a problem with something about me before they ever had the opportunity to show me whether they actually did?

How many times have I made myself smaller, quieter, more agreeable, more attractive, more whatever I thought I needed to be because I was trying to avoid a judgment that hadn’t even happened?

And here’s the part I find especially interesting.

Sometimes we call that being considerate.

We call it being self-aware. Reading the room. Knowing our audience. Being mindful of how we present ourselves.

And sometimes it is.

But sometimes we’re just so accustomed to anticipating somebody else’s discomfort that we don’t even stop to consider our own.

We’re uncomfortable being ourselves, so we assume everybody else must be uncomfortable with us, too.

And then we start managing a reaction that may not even exist.

Now, I do want to make a distinction here.

Because some of us have absolutely been judged for those things.

We’ve had partners criticize our bodies, our clothes, our personalities, the way we laugh, the way we eat, the way we express affection. Some of us have been made to feel that being loved requires being a little less of who we naturally are.

And when you’ve experienced that enough, you learn to anticipate it.

You learn to make adjustments before somebody asks you to.

You learn to pay attention to the smallest changes in somebody’s expression because you’ve learned that those changes might mean something.

So I’m not interested in pretending that every insecurity is something we invented.

Sometimes somebody taught us to be insecure.

But I am interested in what happens when we continue letting those experiences make decisions for us, especially when the people we’re making those decisions around haven’t actually given us a reason to.

Because at what point does protecting ourselves from being rejected become rejecting ourselves first?

That’s a question I’ve had to confront in more than one area of my life.

And not just romantically.

Friendships. Family. Professional relationships. Even the way we show up in spaces where nobody knows us.

We can become so focused on being received well that we forget to pay attention to whether we’re actually being received as ourselves.

And that’s a problem.

Because if somebody likes the version of me I’ve carefully constructed to avoid making them uncomfortable, how much does that really tell me about their ability to love, appreciate, or even understand the person I actually am?

Not much.

It tells me they’re comfortable with what I’ve allowed them to see.

And then I might find myself frustrated that they don’t understand parts of me I’ve been intentionally keeping from them.

See how that works?

Now I’m upset with somebody for not knowing something I haven’t given them the opportunity to know.

And I’m not saying everybody deserves access to every part of us. Absolutely not.

Privacy is not the same thing as pretending. Discernment is not the same thing as fear. And being intentional about who gets access to you is not the same thing as believing the real you is too much for somebody to handle.

Those distinctions matter.

Especially when we’re talking about intimacy.

Because intimacy requires a certain willingness to be witnessed.

Not performed for. Not evaluated. Witnessed.

And that can be uncomfortable when you’ve spent a significant amount of your life learning how to control what other people see.

There’s something almost ridiculous about wanting somebody to know us deeply while simultaneously trying to make sure they never see anything we think they might not like.

We want to be loved unconditionally, but we’re over here submitting a heavily edited application for the position.

And then wondering why being loved still feels exhausting.

Girl.

At some point, we have to put the résumé down.

And I say that with love because I understand how difficult that can be.

I also understand that becoming comfortable with ourselves doesn’t mean we suddenly stop caring what other people think.

We’re human. Connection matters. Belonging matters. Being accepted by the people we love matters.

But I don’t want my desire to be accepted to become more important than my ability to be authentic.

And I don’t want to confuse somebody else’s preferences with requirements for my worthiness.

Somebody can prefer something different from what I naturally do, wear, enjoy, or express without that meaning something is wrong with me.

And I can consider their preferences without making myself responsible for becoming them.

That’s another distinction.

Because relationships do involve consideration, compromise, and growth. We’re not supposed to walk around refusing to examine ourselves under the guise of authenticity.

But growth should not require the abandonment of self.

And love shouldn’t require us to remain in a constant state of self-monitoring.

I want to be able to laugh without wondering whether my laugh was attractive.

Dance without wondering whether I look ridiculous.

Try something I’m terrible at without turning it into a referendum on my competence.

Be quiet without feeling obligated to entertain somebody.

Be excited without worrying that I’m being too much.

Be a whole human being.

And I want the people I love to have that same freedom with me.

Because I also have to consider how my own expectations, reactions, and judgments might make somebody else feel that they need to perform in order to be accepted.

It’s easy to talk about wanting somebody who lets us be ourselves.

But are we creating that same kind of space for them?

Can they be awkward? Uncertain? Emotional? Inexperienced? Different from what we expected?

Can they disappoint our preferences without us making them feel inadequate as a person?

Because I don’t want to demand a kind of acceptance I’m unwilling to practice.

And ultimately, that’s what this brought me back to.

Not whether somebody will love me with my bonnet on.

Not whether somebody finds every single thing about me attractive.

But whether I am willing to stop treating my own humanity as something I need to apologize for before somebody else has even had a chance to experience it.

And whether I can recognize the difference between somebody actually rejecting me and me being so afraid of rejection that I never really let them meet me.

Because those are two very different experiences.

And I don’t want to keep confusing them.

I am becoming somebody who can be loved without feeling obligated to be impressive.

Somebody who can be seen without needing to control every interpretation.

Somebody who can receive affection without immediately searching for the conditions attached to it.

And somebody who understands that being myself will not make me everybody’s person.

It isn’t supposed to.

But I would much rather discover that somebody doesn’t appreciate who I actually am than spend my life being appreciated for somebody I’m exhausted from pretending to be.

And that’s something I’m still learning.

Because knowing that I deserve to be loved as I am and actually allowing myself to be loved that way are two entirely different practices.

IAM Becoming.

And part of that becoming is learning to stop auditioning for a love that says it already wants me.


Sumn to Think On

1. What parts of yourself do you find yourself hiding, adjusting, or apologizing for because you assume somebody else won’t appreciate them?

2. When you feel judged, how often is that judgment something somebody has actually expressed, and how often is it something you’ve anticipated based on previous experiences?

3. If you stopped trying to be the version of yourself you believe other people would find easiest to love, what would you finally give yourself permission to do?


Inspired by a reflection shared by Dr. Kiana Berry (@drkianaberry) on Instagram about self-consciousness, projection, and allowing ourselves to be comfortable in intimacy.